Health Savings Accounts: Will They Work in India?
Caption
Healthcare costs in India are rising steadily: consultation fees, diagnostics, medicines, outpatient care - much of this still comes from your pocket (so-called out-of-pocket expenses). Insurance often addresses hospitalisation, but many recurring costs evade coverage. Enter the idea of a health savings account: a dedicated savings instrument for medical needs, paired with tax advantages, that smooths your health spending over time. In global markets, health savings accounts (HSAs) have gained traction. But can this concept succeed in India?
A health savings account is a specially designated savings account where you deposit money (perhaps pre-tax or tax-advantaged) to use for medical expenses over time. The core idea: you accumulate a medical fund in advance, pay for many health costs out of it, and possibly enjoy tax benefits on contributions or withdrawals. In India, the concept is still in its infancy. Some banks or fintechs are piloting medical-savings style products.
Here's the typical flow in countries where HSAs are mature (adapted to the Indian context):
So, how do health savings accounts work in practice? They act like a cushion: whenever you need to see a specialist, run tests, or buy medicines, you draw from your HSA. Over time, you build an emergency medical corpus. Example: Suppose you deposit ₹1,000 a month. Over a year, you accumulate ₹12,000 + interest. When you see a doctor and incur ₹1,500 in tests, you draw from this. The leftover stays and continues growing. In jurisdictions with mature HSA frameworks, these accounts are coupled with high-deductible health insurance (you pay up to a threshold, then insurance kicks in), so you use your savings for smaller costs and insurance for catastrophic ones.
Globally, there are several models or variants of health savings accounts. Some are pure savings, others are hybrid. Key types:
These different types of health savings accounts vary by who funds them, tax treatment, rollover rules, and what expenses qualify.
When structured well, health savings accounts offer several advantages. Let’s break them down in India’s possible future context.
Other benefits include:· Reduced reliance on high-interest borrowing during medical emergencies.· Encourages health consciousness (if people “see” their savings tied to health).· In some models, it can be used as a tax-efficient savings vehicle.
This is critical: what can health savings accounts be used for? Use depends on jurisdiction, but generally:· Doctor consultation & specialist fees· Diagnostic tests, scans, and lab investigations· Medicines, prescriptions, and sometimes over-the-counter (if rules allow)· Preventive care, screenings, vaccinations· Dental, vision, hearing, physiotherapy (if qualified)· Hospitalisation costs (co-pay, deductible)· Medical travel or procedure-related costs, in some cases· Some plans may permit usage for family members. In India’s future HSA model, these categories are likely. The clarity around “qualified medical expenses” is crucial - there must be a well-defined list to prevent misuse.
To understand what works, let’s look at top models in other markets (benchmarks):· U.S. HSA model: Often held up as the gold standard. Triple tax benefit, rollover, portability, investment options.· Singapore’s Medisave / Medisave + MediShield: Compulsory saving, integrated with public health schemes.· South Africa’s medical savings accounts: As a complement to health insurance for day-to-day medical costs.· Some private health insurers and fintechs globally are launching hybrid HSA + wellness accounts with rewards and investment overlays. The best health savings accounts globally combine:1. Tax incentives (deduction, tax-free growth, tax-free withdrawal)2. Rollover / no expiry3. Flexibility in usage4. Low fees and transparency5. Investment opportunities for surplus funds6. Easy interface, integration with insurers/hospitals These benchmarks teach that HSAs must be simple, low-cost, and embedded.
What can India learn from these global models?· Tax infrastructure is essential: Without favourable tax treatment, adoption will be low.· Partnership with insurers & hospitals: To define “qualified expenses” and enable seamless debit/credit.· Low-cost administrative model: Lower fees will encourage uptake.· Clear regulation: To prevent misuse, set guardrails.· Education & awareness: Many Indians don’t plan for outpatient costs or diagnostics.· Gradual rollout: Start with a pilot in metros or corporate schemes.· Link to existing banking/fintech systems to scale quickly. A KPMG white paper had previously explored the feasibility of HSAs for India, analysing U.S. and Singapore models for learning. Also, media commentary notes HSAs can complement insurance by handling “low-cost, high-frequency” medical needs better than hospitalisation plans alone. Thus, India should consider HSAs as augmenting (not replacing) health insurance.
Yes - but with caveats.
HSAs and health insurance should not be viewed as substitutes - rather, as complementary:· Health insurance handles catastrophic risk hospitalisation, major surgeries).· HSA handles everyday medical costs (consultations, labs, medicines).· Combined, they cover more fully and reduce reliance on out-of-pocket spend. Scenario: You deposit ₹8,000/year to your HSA. Over time, it accumulates. You also hold a general hospitalisation plan. For diagnostic tests, you draw from HSA; for major surgery or a hospital stay, insurance steps in. This integration requires backend linking (e.g., insurers verifying your HSA balance or enabling reimbursements). In India, insurance players could partner with banks / fintechs to offer a “Health Savings + Insurance bundle” product.
Health savings accounts represent a promising way to empower individuals financially for health-related costs. Globally, mature HSA models prove that tax-advantaged, rollover-friendly medical savings work well, especially when paired with insurance. In India, the concept is in its infancy, but the structural need is strong. For HSAs to succeed in India, several pieces must align: tax incentives, regulatory support, careful product design (allowed expense list, penalties, rollover rules), and education. If done right, HSAs can reduce the burden of everyday medical costs, smooth expenditure cycles, and reinforce healthcare resilience for millions of Indians.
As of now, there is no mainstream, nationwide regulatory product labelled “health savings account” with full tax benefits in India. Some banks or fintechs may pilot savings accounts with medical features/incentives, but a full-fledged HSA with recognised tax advantage is not generally available.
Typically: doctor consults, lab tests, diagnostic scans, outpatient treatments, prescription medicines, preventive checkups, dental/vision/physio (if defined), co-pays, and hospital deductibles. The precise list depends on product rules.
Currently, India does not have a formal tax regime for HSAs akin to U.S. HSAs. For a health savings account to attract adoption, new tax provisions would likely be required (deductibility on deposit, tax-free growth, tax-free medical withdrawals). Until then, these would be ordinary savings from post-tax income.
· An HSA is a savings/investment account to pay medical expenses over time.· Health insurance is a contract that reimburses or pays for medical treatment, especially significant ones.· HSAs cover small, frequent expenses; insurance covers high-cost, low-frequency events.· HSAs allow accumulation, rollover, and self-direction; insurance depends on policy terms, premiums, waiting, and exclusions.
